Sin City (2005) – Movie Review

Sin City movie poster Jessica Alba

Written by Robert Rodriguez, based on the series of graphics novels by Frank Miller
Directed by Frank Miller, Robert Rodriguez & Quentin Tarantino
Starring Mickey Rourke, Bruce Willis, Jessica Alba, Clive Owen, Rosario Dawson

My Advice: Don’t miss it.

Welcome to Basin City. It’s a freaking cesspool of sex, violence and depravity. A series of stories from the town come to light. First, an about-to-retire cop (Willis) gets involved with his last case and finds himself in some serious shit. Next, a dangerous nutjob (Rourke) has a night he’ll never forget with a young lady, only to wake up with her dead in bed next to him. And a guy named Dwight (Owen) finds himself in the middle of a war between the ladies of the evening who control Old Town, the mob that wants in, and the cops. Before everything’s said and done there will be carnage, blood, gore, and rampant disregard for most anything civilized. Sweet.

This movie is amazing. I have no idea where to begin listing all the things it does right. First, Rodriguez had the testicular fortitude to insist on including Miller in the mix to bring the graphic novels to light–so much so that he quit the DGA so Miller could share credit. Miller has a nice cameo as a priest, I might add. The movie is literally the graphic novels brought to life by flesh and blood actors and a crapload of computer effects to mimic Miller’s stark backgrounds.

The similarities between the movie and the book are positively mind-blowing. It’s literally a comic book sprung to life with a good number of shots in the films taken verbatim from the comics. And the effects are stunning. Even if it’s something small, like how Rodriguez can make Marv’s (Rourke) face disappear but for his bandaids. Or the few splotches of color that decorate the film. You could watch it just for its technical achievement and how gorgeous the damn thing is and stay busy the whole time.

Trouble is you barely get a chance, because this ensemble cast is kicking much ass all the way around. I racked my brain to come up with a situation that felt forced or a character that seemed slightly out of whack and could not. Even if you haven’t read the comics, you can quickly see where it’s all coming from: this is noir laced with rocket fuel.

Mickey Rourke gives an amazing performance. He’s Marv. He is Marv. You forget you’re watching Mickey Rourke on the screen, he’s so completely the character. And it’s not just the amount of prosthetics they use to turn him into Marv–which look much better in the film than they have in stills. Mickey Rourke blows me away with his acting and Elijah Wood creeps the hell out of me? I swear to God, I don’t understand the universe anymore. Also notable is Bruce Willis in all of his stoic glory and Clive Owen, who looks to be having the time of his freaking life.

A bit of a warning, though: I’m amazed this thing got an R. It has probably some of the creepiest things I’ve seen on the screen in a while, not to mention some very disturbing bits, on top of some extreme violence that you have to question whether or not you’ve actually seen what you’ve just seen. But it’s a ride–a completely flawless, nasty, out of control balls to the wall ride. And probably one of the best comic adaptations we will ever see.

By | 2017-09-24T23:59:23+00:00 April 1st, 2005|Reviews|3 Comments

3 Comments

  1. Martin August 25, 2005 at 12:20 pm

    a totally cool movie! surreal in it’s atmosphere and unapologetically violent, but didn’t leave me feeling “dirty” ’cause it’s so tongue-in-cheek. Even Elijah Wood wasn’t miscast as i thought he would be, show’s how effecient Rodriquez and co. are. On my ten point rating, it gets a 9 {hey, c’mon, nothing, movies included, are PERFECT!}

  2. Paladin March 26, 2006 at 2:24 am

    Loved it. Didn’t know what to expect going in, but was thoroughly impressed. Each character is well developed and fascinating. Elijah Wood (“Kevin”) is so odd and frighteningly good in this role. Rourke (“Marv”) has some great lines. Definitely hard “R” rating for a couple gruesome scenes. Jessica Alba (“Nancy”) is lovely to watch. Each plot is seemlessly integrated. Check it out.

  3. Greg April 22, 2009 at 1:59 am

    could not agree more; if anything, its underrated

Leave A Comment

%d bloggers like this: