Ah, the movie musical. Hollywood and the moviegoing public has fallen in and out of love with you seemingly dependent on which way the wind is blowing. It's only in recent years with entries like Moulin Rouge and Chicago that Hollywood has figured out--like with most things--that if just do the damn thing correctly (or at the very least, in a flawed but interesting fashion)--we'll show up. And of course we have the slow march of Broadway musicals through development hell to the big screen--and the reverse pollination of movies into musicals and onto Broadway. The obvious success story for this has been the rejuvenation of Mel Brooks but other titles like Lion King and Spamalot spring to mind.
Forming a syllabus for a decent master class in movie musicals, you get the Musicals edition of the line of Best of Warner Brothers: 20 Film Collections. Let's be clear and get the obvious question out of the way front and center: no, there's nothing new here. As you probably suspected, when you open the three cases (split up into different time spans (1927-1951, 1951-1964 and 1967-1988--that's right, don't be looking for Cats Don't Dance) you see that you've got the primary discs from the previous DVD releases of these titles. You do get the bonus features that came on those discs, so that's something, yes? Especially when it's some gems like the Frank Oz commentary on Little Shop of Horrors, the historian commentary on Wizard of Oz, and all the vintage featurettes and shorts that come on the older titles. (Full list of titles to follow.)
All of that accepted and the audience expectations in place, the only caveat I can see is that the cases for the three volumes inside the boxed set are poorly conceived. The final discs in two of the volumes had come loose and were thus badly scratched from banging around...and the final disc in the third volume was just barely hanging on by the time it reached me. So if you do order this, open it immediately and if yours is scratched up, send it back and continue to do so until you get lucky or they fix the damn thing. It's a shame to have such a great deal marred by poor packaging. I appreciate trying to cram as many discs into as small a space as possible, but if we can't watch the discs when they get here, that's a bit of a problem.
Recommended for the thrifty musical lover with that caveat in place.
Full List of Films Included: